Islamization of Aesthetics
(A Critical Study of The Prevailing Perception of Islamic Aesthetics)
Abstract
This study examines the debate about Islamic Aesthetics, the concept of Islamic aesthetics, the possibility of the existence of so-called Islamic aesthetics. Moreover, a review of Arab and Islamic visions, the first is the adoption of the presence of Islamic aesthetics, and the second is the denial of its existence, through a critical methodology that attempts to reveal the philosophical and logical confusion that affected some Writings in Islamic Art and Aesthetics. The study tries to answer some of its questions about the history of the emergence of the term Islamic Aesthetics and the concept of Islamic aesthetics from the two visions supporting its existence and depriving it, and what is the possibility of there being Islamic aesthetics?
The results of this study showed that the term Islamic Aesthetic or the term Islamic Beauty is not found in old Arabic Islamic writings that appeared before the twentieth century. Also, the term (Islamic aesthetics) did not appear clearly except through the cultural movement carried out by the International Institute of Islamic Thought in the eighties of the twentieth century. The study also showed that the vision supporting the existence of Islamic aesthetics adopts two locations. The first position is to demonstrate Arab aesthetics, mentioned in the writings of early Arab thinkers such as al-Tawhidi, Ibn Sina, Ibn Hazm, al-Ghazali, and Ibn al-Qayyim al-Jawziyya. The second position adopts the idea that Islamic aesthetics is a modern science but has its roots and backgrounds in the concept of beauty in the Holy Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet. As for the vision that denies the existence of Islamic aesthetics, it believes that what came in the Arabic and Islamic writings that claim to be Islamic aesthetics is ambiguity and fallacies between studying Islamic beauty and Aesthetics. Also, the results of the research showed confusion between research in Islamic Beauty, and research in Aesthetics that produced the term (Islamic Aesthetics), and this confusion arose from reasons including intolerance to the Islamization of knowledge, and any attempt to approach philosophy. For beauty between the intellectual trends of Islam and expressive art forms that reflect those intellectual trends and an attempt to consolidate the theory of Islamic art based on Islamic beauty.
References
2. برهومة، عيسى عودة (2017). قراءة في كتاب الفن في الفكر الإسلامي: رؤية معرفية ومنهجية. مجلة إسلامية المعرفة، (88)، 149-162.
3. البهنسي، عفيف (1979). جماليات الفن العربي. الكويت: المجلس الوطني للثقافة والفنون والآداب.
4. توفيق، سعيد (1992). الخبرة الجمالية دراسة في فلسفة الجمال الظاهراتية. بيروت، لبنان: المؤسسة الجامعية للدراسات والنشر والتوزيع.
5. توفيق، سعيد (د.ت). تهافت مفهوم علم الجمال الإسلامي. القاهرة، مصر: دار قباء.
6. حنش، إدهام محمد (2013). نظرية الفن الإسلامي عند المفكر إسماعيل الفاروقي، مجلة إسلامية المعرفة، (74)، 117-149.
7. الخوالدة، محمود؛ الترتوري، محمد (2006). التربية الجمالية: علم نفس الجمال، الأردن، عمّان: دار الشروق.
8. السورجي، جميل علي (2012). مفهوم الجمال في الفكر الإسلامي. مجلة الشريعة والدراسات الإسلامية، (20)، 98-164
9. السيف، خالد عبد العزيز (2015). إشكالية المصطلح في الفكر العربي المعاصر. مجلة كلية أصول الدين بأسيوط، (33)، 1505-1573.
10. عبيدي، سعيد (2017، أبريل 19). أسلمة المعرفة: المفهوم والمشروع ]مقال[ تم الاسترجاع من موقع https://www.msf-online.com/
11. العلواني، طه جابر (2001). اصلاح الفكر الإسلامي مدخل إلى نظام الخطاب في الفكر الإسلامي. بيروت، لبنان: دار الهادي.
12. العمر، عبد الله محمد (2015). معايير الجمال في الرؤيتين الإسلامية والغربية. مجلة العلوم الشرعية، (38)، 441-480.
13. الفاروقي، إسماعيل راجي (1983). أسلمة المعرفة المبادئ العامة وخطة العمل، (ترجمة عبد الوارث سعيد). الكويت: دار البحوث العلمية.
14. قلعة جي، عبد الفتاح رواس (1991). مدخل إلى علم الجمال الإسلامي. بيروت، لبنان: دار قتيبة.
15. الكحلاوي، محمد (2017، يوليو). الأفق الفكري لجماليات الفن الإسلامي محاولة في تأويل العلامة وتجليات المقدس. مؤمنة بلا حدود للأبحاث والدراسات. تم الاسترجاع من موقع https://www.mominoun.com/articles/
16. مطر، أميرة حلمي (2013). مدخل إلى علم الجمال وفلسفة الفن. القاهرة، مصر: دار التنوير.
References
1. Ibrahim, Sami Mahmoud (2013). Beauty Concepts in Islamic Philosophy and Its Comparison With Western Philosophies. In Fathi Malkawi (Ed), Art in Islamic Thought (pp. 93-122). Beirut, Lebanon: International Institute for Islamic Thought.
2. Barhoma, Issa Odah (2017). Reading in The Book of Art in Islamic Thought: A Cognitive and Methodological View. Islamiyyat AlMa'rifah Journal, (88), 149-162.
3. Al-Bahnasy, Afif (1979). Aesthetics of Arab Art. Kuwait: The National Council for Culture, Arts and Letters.
4. Tawfik, Saeed (1992). Aesthetic Experience is A Study in The Philosophy of Phenomenal Beauty. Beirut, Lebanon: University Foundation for Studies, Publishing and Distribution.
5. Tawfik, Saeed (n.d.) Crumble the Concept of Islamic Aesthetics. Cairo, Egypt: Dar Quba.
6. Hanash, Edham Muhammad (2013). Islamic Art Theory of the Thinker (Ismail Al-Farouqi), Islamiyyat AlMa'rifah Journal, (74), 117-149.
7. Al-Khawaldah, Mahmoud; Al-Tartori, Mohammed (2006). Aesthetic Education: Beauty Psychology, Jordan, Amman: Dar Al-Shorouk.
8. Al-Sorji, Jamil Ali (2012). The Concept of Beauty in Islamic Thought. Journal of Sharia and Islamic Studies, (20), 98-164.
9. Al-Seef, Khaled Abdul Aziz (2015). The Problematic of The Term in Contemporary Arab Thought. Journal of the Faculty of Fundamentals of Religion, Assiut, (33), 1505-1573.
10. Abedi, Saeed (2017, April 19). Islamization of Knowledge: Concept and Project [Article]. Retrieved from https://www.msf-online.com/
11. Al-Alwani, Taha Jaber (2001). Reforming Islamic Thought: An Introduction to The Discourse System of Islamic Thought. Beirut, Lebanon: Dar Al-Hadi.
12. Al-Omar, Abdullah Muhammad (2015). Beauty Standards in Islamic and Western Visions. Journal of Sharia Sciences, (38), 441-480.
13. Al-Faruqi, Ismail Raji (1983). Islamization of Knowledge, General Principles and Work Plan, "trans Abdel-Warith Saeed". Kuwait: Dar Albhuth Alelmia.
14. Qala'h Gee, Abdel-Fattah Rawas (1991). Introduction to Islamic Aesthetics. Beirut, Lebanon: Dar Qutaiba.
15. Al-Kahlawy, Muhammad (2017, July). The Intellectual Horizon of The Beauty of Islamic Art is an Attempt to Interpret The Sign and Manifestations of The Sacred. Mominoun Without Borders for research and studies. Retrieved from
https://www.mominoun.com/articles/
16. Matar, Amira Helmy (2013). Introduction to Aesthetics and The Philosophy of Art. Cairo, Egypt: Dar Al Tanweer.
17. Bagheripoor, Ashraf (2018). Aesthetic Manifestation of Designs & Ornaments in Islamic Tile-Work Style. International Journal of Arts, 8(3): 47-52
18. Erzen, Jalle Nejdet (2007). Islamic Aesthetics: An Alternative Way to Knowledge. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 65 (1): 69-75.
19. Gonzalez, Valerie (2001). Beauty and Islam Aesthetics in Islamic Art and Architecture. New York: I.B.Tauris.
20. Gonzalez, Valerie (2003). Beauty. Richard C.Martin, Encyclopedia of Islam & the Muslim World, 2nd ed (pp.158-163).
21. Grabar, Oleg (1978). The Formation of Islamic Art. New Haven: Yale University Press.
22. M.S. Demand (1930). A Handbook of Muhammadan Decorative Arts. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art.